Geek Out #13
Do ECs really beat private condos after 5 and 10 years?
Published · URA caveat records, resales from October 2021 to October 2026
Yes. Between October 2021 and October 2026, executive condos sold 5 years after completion increased in value by a median 7.0% a year, while 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region increased by 3.5% a year. Sold 10 years after completion: 5.2% and 3.6% a year. I compared only units bought from the developer, and only units of 900 sqft or more, the size of most EC units.
What this page found, in 6 lines
At the MOP, executive condos increased in value by 7.0% a year, private condos by 3.5%. · tap for the rest
- At the MOP, 5 years after completion: executive condos increased in value by a median 7.0% a year, and private condos by 3.5%.
- At 10 years after completion: executive condos increased in value by 5.2% a year, and private condos by 3.6%.
- All 1,932 executive condo sales at the MOP and at 10 years after completion made a profit.
- At 10 years after completion, executive condos sold for about the same psf as private condos. The executive condo buyers had paid about 15% less per sqft.
- Executive condos also increased more in value each year than private condos within 2km bought and sold at about the same time: all 14 tested at the MOP and all 24 at 10 years after completion.
- ECs haven’t always made money: 109 of 110 sales of older ECs at the MOP, in 2004 and 2005, lost money. Private condos sold in those years lost money too: 92 of 96 sales.
At the MOPAt 10 yearsWhyDoes it hold up?Full privatisationOlder ECsNew 10-year MOPQuestions
How much did EC owners make at the MOP?
A median 7.0% a year. That’s for executive condo (EC) units of 900 sqft or more, bought from the developer and sold in the 5th year after completion, between October 2021 and October 2026. 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region (OCR), bought from the developer and sold in the same year after completion, increased in value by 3.5% a year. I compared ECs with 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region because every EC here is in that region, and ECs have 99-year leases too.
| ECs | Private condos (OCR) | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 1,34127 projects | 35436 projects |
| Yearly gain | 7.0% | 3.5% |
| Total gain | 56% | 29% |
| Paid | $849,000 | $1,244,000 |
| Profit | $481,000 | $360,000 |
| Price paid | $784 psf | $1,104 psf |
| Price sold | $1,235 psf | $1,446 psf |
| Years owned | 6.8 | 7.7 |
| Sold at a loss | 0 | 9 |
Medians. “Paid” and “profit” are for the whole unit; price paid and price sold are $ psf.
An EC owner who sold at the MOP had owned the unit for a median 6.8 years, not 5, because the MOP runs 5 years from the date the EC gets its Temporary Occupation Permit (TOP), and the units were bought before that. Many of these ECs were still selling units a year or more after launch. Owners who bought within 6 months of their EC’s first recorded sale owned their units for a median 7.4 years, and their units increased in value by 6.7% a year. A buyer who books at launch waits for the EC to be completed, then another 5 years.
Private condo buyers in the Outside Central Region waited for completion too. Those who sold in the same year after completion had owned their units for a median 7.7 years.
The EC owners also made more in dollars, even though they paid less. The typical EC unit cost about $849,000 and made about $481,000. The typical 99-year private condo unit in the Outside Central Region cost about $1,244,000 and made about $360,000.
How much did EC owners make 10 years after completion?
A median 5.2% a year, for EC units of 900 sqft or more sold in the 10th year after completion. 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region (OCR), sold in the same year after completion, increased in value by 3.6% a year. Under the rules for these ECs, the 10th year after completion is when an EC is fully privatised and can be sold to anyone, including foreigners.
| ECs | Private condos (OCR) | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 59126 projects | 77863 projects |
| Yearly gain | 5.2% | 3.6% |
| Total gain | 87% | 58% |
| Paid | $843,000 | $1,021,000 |
| Profit | $756,000 | $600,000 |
| Price paid | $743 psf | $877 psf |
| Price sold | $1,397 psf | $1,390 psf |
| Years owned | 12.7 | 13.0 |
| Sold at a loss | 0 | 2 |
Medians. “Paid” and “profit” are for the whole unit; price paid and price sold are $ psf.
The typical EC unit cost about $843,000 and made about $756,000, over 12.7 years of ownership. The typical 99-year private condo unit in the Outside Central Region cost about $1,021,000 and made about $600,000.
Yearly gain, from the 5th to the 12th year after completion
The EC yearly gain was highest at the MOP and smaller for units sold later. For private condos it was smallest in the 6th year and larger after that. The gap between ECs and private condos narrowed, but ECs increased more in value in every year from the 5th to the 12th.
- Blue line and dots: executive condos.
- Orange dashed line and squares: 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region.
- Each point: the median yearly gain of units of 900 sqft or more, bought from the developer and sold in that year after completion, October 2021 to October 2026. The 5th year is the MOP; the 10th year is when these ECs were fully privatised. The number of sales behind each point is in the table under “How the numbers were worked out”.
What got me thinking about this
Clients who own an EC ask me the same thing every year: sell at the MOP, or hold? And upgraders ask whether an EC is a better buy than a private condo. Everyone says ECs make more, so I got curious how much more, and whether it still holds after 10 years. Then somehow it was 2am.

Why did ECs make more than private condos?
Because EC buyers paid much less per sqft, and by the time they sold, most of that gap had closed. At the MOP, EC buyers had paid a median $784 psf and sold at $1,235 psf. Private condo buyers in the Outside Central Region had paid $1,104 psf and sold at $1,446 psf. So the ECs were bought for about 29% less per sqft and sold for about 15% less.
At 10 years after completion, the EC buyers had paid about 15% less per sqft ($743 psf, compared with $877 psf for private condos) and sold for about the same ($1,397 psf, compared with $1,390 psf).
The lower price comes with conditions. An EC is first sold to Singaporean families within an income ceiling, and its owners must live in it for the MOP before they can sell it or rent out the whole unit. For the latest income ceilings, see HDB and EC income ceilings raised in 2026. For what one family did with their EC gain, read my EC to private property upgrade case study.
These are the prices buyers paid the developer, before any CPF housing grant.
Does the result hold up?
Yes. ECs increased more in value each year than 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region when I compared them in four other ways:
- Same unit size: in all three size bands, from 900 sqft to 1,300 sqft or more, at the MOP and at 10 years.
- Same purchase year: in each of the 6 purchase years from 2013 to 2018 at the MOP, and the 5 from 2010 to 2014 at 10 years.
- Same year of sale: in every year of sale from 2021 to 2025 at the MOP, and from 2023 to 2026 at 10 years.
- Private condos within 2km, bought and sold at about the same time: all 14 ECs that could be tested at the MOP, and all 24 at 10 years.
The tables for each check are under “How the numbers were worked out”.
Does an EC’s price jump when it’s fully privatised?
A little, for recent ECs. Under the old rules, an EC was fully privatised 10 years after completion. Of 15 ECs fully privatised between 2023 and 2025, 11 increased in price by more than private condos in the same postal district from their 9th to their 11th year after completion, by a median 2.8 percentage points. Of 9 ECs privatised between 2009 and 2015, 4 increased by more.
| Fully privatised | ECs tested | Increased in price by more | Median difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 to 2025 | 15 | 11 | +2.8 points |
| 2009 to 2015 | 9 | 4 | −0.7 points |
These are the only ECs with enough sales in both years to test. Each EC’s result is under “How the numbers were worked out”. Difference: change in the EC’s median price psf minus the change for private condos in its district, in percentage points.
Did ECs always beat private condos?
Compared with private condos sold in the same year, they did as well or better, but they didn’t always make money. ECs completed in 1999 and 2000 reached their MOP in 2004 and 2005, when prices were lower than when their owners bought, and 109 of their 110 sales at the MOP lost money. Private condos sold in those two years lost money too: 92 of 96 sales.
| Sold | Older ECs | Private condos |
|---|---|---|
| At the MOP2004 and 2005 | −2.5%110 sales109 lost money | −4.1%96 sales92 lost money |
| At the MOP2008 to 2010 | +7.4%141 sales0 lost money | +3.8%405 sales8 lost money |
| 10 years after completion2009 | +2.2%56 sales0 lost money | −0.3%209 sales129 lost money |
| 10 years after completion2010 | +3.0%282 sales0 lost money | +3.0%163 sales11 lost money |
| 10 years after completion2013 | +6.4%13 sales0 lost money | +5.7%41 sales0 lost money |
| 10 years after completion2015 | +6.2%10 sales0 lost money | +5.4%28 sales0 lost money |
Median yearly gain, with the number of sales and how many lost money. ECs and 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region completed between 1999 and 2005, units of 900 sqft or more, bought from the developer. Only years in which older ECs were sold are shown.
What do ten years of EC records say about the new 10-year MOP?
They show how much EC units increased in value by 10 years after completion, which is when owners of the newest ECs will first be able to sell. For EC sites whose land tender closed on or after 8 May 2026, the MOP is 10 years, full privatisation comes after 15 years, and the Deferred Payment Scheme is no longer offered. ECs on sites tendered before then keep the 5-year MOP.
Two things are different. The ECs in these records could be sold to anyone 10 years after completion; ECs under the new rules can be sold only to Singapore citizens and permanent residents until 15 years after completion. And these records are past sales of ECs bought between 2010 and 2019, not a forecast of what a new EC will make.
Thinking of selling your EC at its MOP, or buying one? WhatsApp me the project’s name and I’ll send you its resale records.
Ask me on WhatsAppQuestions people ask about this

Do ECs make more money than private condos?
Yes, from October 2021 to October 2026. EC units of 900 sqft or more, bought from the developer, increased in value by a median 7.0% a year when sold 5 years after completion, and 5.2% at 10 years. 99-year private condos in the Outside Central Region increased by 3.5% and 3.6%. All 24 ECs tested at 10 years increased more in value each year than private condos within 2km. Any CPF housing grant an EC buyer got isn’t counted.
When can I sell my EC?
After the Minimum Occupation Period (MOP), counted from the date the EC gets its Temporary Occupation Permit. For ECs on sites whose land tender closed before 8 May 2026, the MOP is 5 years, after which owners can sell to Singapore citizens and permanent residents, and the EC is fully privatised after 10 years. For sites tendered on or after 8 May 2026, the MOP is 10 years and full privatisation 15 years.
Does an EC’s price jump after it’s fully privatised?
A little, for recent ECs. Of 15 ECs fully privatised between 2023 and 2025, 11 increased in price by more than private condos in the same postal district from their 9th to their 11th year after completion, by a median 2.8 percentage points. ECs privatised between 2009 and 2015 were mixed: 4 of 9.
Will ECs launched under the May 2026 rules make the same returns?
These records can’t say. They are past sales of ECs bought between 2010 and 2019. ECs on sites tendered from 8 May 2026 have a 10-year MOP and can’t be sold to foreigners until 15 years after completion, so their owners wait longer to sell, and at 10 years can sell only to Singapore citizens and permanent residents.
Did ECs completed in the late 1990s and early 2000s beat private condos?
Compared with private condos sold in the same year, they did as well or better, but they didn’t always make money. Almost every EC sold at the MOP in 2004 or 2005 lost money (109 of 110 sales), and so did private condos sold in those years (92 of 96). ECs sold at the MOP between 2008 and 2010 increased in value by 7.4% a year, and private condos by 3.8%.
Tell me which one and I’ll check its records and update the page.
Message me on WhatsApp
How the numbers were worked out
- The records: URA caveat records, matched into resale pairs. Each pair is one unit bought and later sold. The ECs and private condos on this page were all sold between 12 October 2021 and 9 October 2026, because for 57 of the ECs the records only start in October 2021.
- Bought from the developer: the records don’t say who the seller was, so a unit counts as bought from the developer if it was bought in or before its completion year.
- 5 and 10 years after completion: sold in the 5th or the 10th calendar year after the project’s completion year. The records give completion as a year, not a date. The MOP and 10-year figures mostly cover different ECs, because my records start in October 2021.
- Private condos: private condos and apartments in URA’s Outside Central Region (OCR) on 99-year leases. Every EC on this page is also in the OCR.
- Unit size: the headline figures cover units of 900 sqft or more. The records give each unit’s size, not its number of bedrooms, and some ECs have 2-bedroom units smaller than 900 sqft.
- Yearly gain: the price gain spread over the years owned, compounded. It leaves out stamp duty, agent fees, loan interest and any grant.
- Sales before the MOP: 152 of 9,471 EC sales were recorded before the 5th year after completion. They fall outside both checkpoints, so they aren’t in any figure.
- A second check: each EC sale was compared with private condo sales in the same postal district, bought in the same year, sold in the same year after completion, and within 10% of its size. At the MOP, 1,270 of 1,696 EC sales had a match, and 95% of those increased more in value each year. At 10 years, 571 of 670 had a match, and 99% increased more in value each year.
- Nearby private condos: within 2km in a straight line between the two projects’ locations, units of 900 sqft or more, bought within one year of the EC units and sold within one year of them, at least a year after the private condo’s own completion year. Each EC needs at least 10 sales, and at least 10 nearby private condo sales. Within 3km, 23 ECs could be tested at the MOP and 23 increased more in value each year; at 10 years, 26 could be tested and 26 increased more.
- Full privatisation: ECs with at least 5 sales in both the 9th and the 11th year after completion, compared with private condos in the same postal district with at least 10 sales in each of those two calendar years.
- Older ECs: ECs and private condos completed between 1999 and 2005, sold before October 2021. They are compared with private condos sold in the same year, because prices moved a lot between 2004 and 2015.
- Update log: 17 November 2026, first published.
By year after completion (the chart)
| Sold in | ECs | Private condos (OCR) |
|---|---|---|
| 5th year | 7.0%(1,341 sales) | 3.5%(354 sales) |
| 6th year | 6.7%(1,536 sales) | 2.9%(512 sales) |
| 7th year | 6.1%(973 sales) | 3.0%(746 sales) |
| 8th year | 5.6%(896 sales) | 3.2%(754 sales) |
| 9th year | 5.4%(844 sales) | 3.4%(814 sales) |
| 10th year | 5.2%(591 sales) | 3.6%(778 sales) |
| 11th year | 5.2%(358 sales) | 3.7%(623 sales) |
| 12th year | 5.0%(167 sales) | 4.0%(327 sales) |
Median yearly gain, with the number of sales in brackets, by the year after completion each unit was sold. Units of 900 sqft or more, bought from the developer, sold October 2021 to October 2026. The chart stops at the 12th year, because after that too few ECs had sales each year.
By unit size
At the MOP:
| Unit size | ECs | Private condos (OCR) |
|---|---|---|
| 900 to 1,099 sqft | 7.2%(815 sales) | 3.4%(194 sales) |
| 1,100 to 1,299 sqft | 6.8%(343 sales) | 3.6%(91 sales) |
| 1,300 sqft or more | 6.4%(183 sales) | 3.7%(69 sales) |
At 10 years after completion:
| Unit size | ECs | Private condos (OCR) |
|---|---|---|
| 900 to 1,099 sqft | 5.1%(280 sales) | 3.5%(307 sales) |
| 1,100 to 1,299 sqft | 5.2%(180 sales) | 3.8%(267 sales) |
| 1,300 sqft or more | 5.2%(131 sales) | 3.5%(204 sales) |
Yearly gain, median, with the number of sales in brackets. Sold October 2021 to October 2026.
Private condos within 2km, bought and sold at about the same time
| ECs compared with private condos within 2km | ECs compared with all private condos in the OCR | |
|---|---|---|
| At the MOP | +2.8 points a year14 ECs | +3.5 points |
| At 10 years | +1.6 points24 ECs | +1.6 points |
At the MOP:
| EC | EC yearly gain | Private condos within 2km | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| The CriterionD27 | 7.9%78 sales | 3.4%90 sales3 condos | +4.5 |
| The ValesD19 | 7.3%88 sales | 3.1%29 sales5 condos | +4.2 |
| BellewatersD19 | 6.5%138 sales | 3.2%99 sales7 condos | +3.3 |
| The TopiaryD28 | 5.0%17 sales | 1.7%29 sales3 condos | +3.3 |
| Twin FountainsD25 | 3.6%12 sales | 0.5%17 sales1 condo | +3.1 |
| ForestvilleD25 | 3.4%21 sales | 0.5%17 sales1 condo | +2.9 |
| Signature at YishunD27 | 7.1%55 sales | 4.2%28 sales2 condos | +2.9 |
| Lush AcresD28 | 5.0%10 sales | 2.3%85 sales6 condos | +2.7 |
| Rivercove ResidencesD19 | 6.9%45 sales | 4.5%45 sales3 condos | +2.4 |
| Skypark ResidencesD27 | 4.7%24 sales | 2.3%28 sales3 condos | +2.4 |
| Citylife@TampinesD18 | 4.4%13 sales | 3.0%109 sales6 condos | +1.4 |
| EcopolitanD19 | 4.3%34 sales | 3.1%124 sales6 condos | +1.2 |
| WaterbayD19 | 4.3%14 sales | 3.1%182 sales7 condos | +1.2 |
| Sea HorizonD18 | 3.6%30 sales | 3.0%167 sales8 condos | +0.6 |
At 10 years after completion:
| EC | EC yearly gain | Private condos within 2km | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| The TopiaryD28 | 5.9%27 sales | 2.8%24 sales2 condos | +3.1 |
| Twin FountainsD25 | 4.7%10 sales | 1.7%17 sales2 condos | +3.0 |
| Skypark ResidencesD27 | 5.9%12 sales | 3.0%28 sales2 condos | +2.9 |
| ForestvilleD25 | 4.3%14 sales | 1.7%17 sales2 condos | +2.6 |
| The RainforestD23 | 5.1%17 sales | 2.5%23 sales4 condos | +2.6 |
| The CanopyD27 | 4.1%17 sales | 1.7%72 sales2 condos | +2.4 |
| Esparina ResidencesD19 | 5.7%20 sales | 3.5%234 sales7 condos | +2.2 |
| The Tampines TrilliantD18 | 6.0%40 sales | 4.0%236 sales8 condos | +2.0 |
| PriveD19 | 5.4%23 sales | 3.6%301 sales6 condos | +1.8 |
| Twin WaterfallsD19 | 5.9%35 sales | 4.1%291 sales6 condos | +1.8 |
| Citylife@TampinesD18 | 5.7%25 sales | 4.0%133 sales6 condos | +1.7 |
| 1 CanberraD27 | 4.8%36 sales | 3.2%108 sales5 condos | +1.6 |
| BelysaD18 | 5.1%15 sales | 3.5%153 sales4 condos | +1.6 |
| Riverparc ResidenceD19 | 5.8%31 sales | 4.2%180 sales4 condos | +1.6 |
| Lush AcresD28 | 5.2%14 sales | 3.9%85 sales5 condos | +1.4 |
| WaterbayD19 | 5.5%17 sales | 4.2%211 sales7 condos | +1.3 |
| WaterwoodsD19 | 5.4%12 sales | 4.1%383 sales9 condos | +1.3 |
| Arc at TampinesD18 | 4.8%32 sales | 3.5%243 sales8 condos | +1.2 |
| Austville ResidencesD19 | 4.8%26 sales | 3.7%361 sales9 condos | +1.1 |
| Heron BayD19 | 4.9%32 sales | 3.8%298 sales8 condos | +1.1 |
| EcopolitanD19 | 5.0%20 sales | 4.3%137 sales6 condos | +0.8 |
| Lake LifeD22 | 4.8%19 sales | 4.2%41 sales2 condos | +0.6 |
| WatercoloursD18 | 4.3%23 sales | 3.7%297 sales9 condos | +0.6 |
| Sea HorizonD18 | 4.3%25 sales | 3.9%211 sales8 condos | +0.4 |
Median yearly gain, with the number of sales under it. Private condos: units within 2km of the EC, bought within a year of the EC units and sold within a year of them, at least a year after their own completion year. Units of 900 sqft or more, sold October 2021 to October 2026. Difference in percentage points.
Full privatisation, each EC
The differences range from +12.8 points at The Tampines Trilliant to −13.8 points at Whitewater.
| EC | EC price change | District private condos | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Tampines TrilliantD18, completed 201545 and 40 sales | +15.9% | +3.1% | +12.8 |
| WaterwoodsD19, completed 201515 and 18 sales | +13.8% | +4.6% | +9.1 |
| WoodsvaleD25, completed 200091 and 77 sales | +41.0% | +32.3% | +8.7 |
| Yew Mei GreenD23, completed 200062 and 33 sales | +41.0% | +33.0% | +8.0 |
| Twin WaterfallsD19, completed 201543 and 30 sales | +12.4% | +4.6% | +7.8 |
| NorthoaksD25, completed 200086 and 84 sales | +39.2% | +32.3% | +6.9 |
| Arc at TampinesD18, completed 201425 and 29 sales | +15.7% | +9.7% | +5.9 |
| BelysaD18, completed 201414 and 21 sales | +15.1% | +9.7% | +5.4 |
| Heron BayD19, completed 201542 and 12 sales | +9.0% | +4.6% | +4.4 |
| The RainforestD23, completed 201531 and 14 sales | +12.4% | +8.1% | +4.2 |
| Riverparc ResidenceD19, completed 201425 and 18 sales | +11.7% | +8.8% | +2.8 |
| Simei Green CondominiumD18, completed 199931 and 58 sales | +20.1% | +17.6% | +2.4 |
| Esparina ResidencesD19, completed 201326 and 48 sales | +22.8% | +20.5% | +2.4 |
| The CanopyD27, completed 201414 and 22 sales | +12.4% | +10.6% | +1.8 |
| 1 CanberraD27, completed 201532 and 18 sales | +8.7% | +8.5% | +0.2 |
| Austville ResidencesD19, completed 201432 and 49 sales | +8.5% | +8.8% | −0.4 |
| The FloravaleD22, completed 200084 and 64 sales | +38.5% | +39.3% | −0.7 |
| The Eden at TampinesD18, completed 200328 and 6 sales | +5.4% | +7.1% | −1.7 |
| PriveD19, completed 201335 and 42 sales | +18.3% | +20.5% | −2.2 |
| WatercoloursD18, completed 201414 and 26 sales | +7.1% | +9.7% | −2.7 |
| SummerdaleD22, completed 200034 and 40 sales | +29.6% | +39.3% | −9.7 |
| The RivervaleD19, completed 200034 and 47 sales | +36.7% | +47.0% | −10.3 |
| Blossom ResidencesD23, completed 201434 and 41 sales | +5.0% | +15.9% | −10.9 |
| WhitewaterD18, completed 20059 and 12 sales | −13.3% | +0.4% | −13.8 |
Change in median price psf from the 9th to the 11th year after completion, with the EC’s number of sales in each of those two years. “District private condos” is every private condo sale in the same postal district in the same two calendar years. Difference in percentage points.
Whitewater’s median price fell from $833 psf in 2013 to $679 in 2017, while private condo resales in D18 stayed around $900 to $980 psf. It was fully privatised in 2015.
Where the numbers come from
- Resale gains: URA caveat records of private residential and executive condo sales, matched into resale pairs by PropertyInsider.sg (9 October 2026 is the latest sale). Each record pairs a unit’s purchase with its later sale; only units that were resold are included. Lodging a caveat isn’t compulsory, so a few sales aren’t recorded.
- EC MOP before May 2026: Ministry of National Development, written answer on conditions for EC owners: a 5-year MOP from the date of the TOP.
- EC rules from 8 May 2026: as announced by the Ministry of National Development on 8 May 2026, reported by EdgeProp.
- Completion years and districts: the project records that come with the caveat records.
- URA regions: URA’s Core Central Region (CCR), Rest of Central Region (RCR) and Outside Central Region (OCR), as used in its property price statistics.
More from Geek Out: New launches cost more than the resale next door. How much more, and what happens to that premium after completion?
Before you act on any of this. These are past resale results from URA’s caveat records, not a forecast of what any EC or private condo will make. Check HDB’s current EC rules and your own eligibility before buying or selling.
Your turn
Got a burning question you're dying to get an answer to?
Send it over. There's no such thing as a silly question — only the ones that keep you up at night.
Ask the Property GeekStay curious. See you down the next rabbit hole.The Property Geek & the corgi